Metricool
Metricool's recent output is blog content, not releases—but the AI tool focus signals the product roadmap
Comparison · Marketing
Umbraco CMS vs TinaCMS
A side-by-side editorial comparison of Umbraco CMS and TinaCMS — release velocity, themes, recent moves, and the top alternatives to consider.
Umbraco CMS vs TinaCMS: at a glance
What is Umbraco CMS?
Umbraco runs parallel release candidates across v13, v17, and v18, with both current tracks approaching their next minor GA.
Umbraco is running a steady cadence of release candidates across three active version tracks: v13 (LTS), v17 (current stable), and v18 (latest). The visible changes are mostly dependency updates and targeted bug fixes. The installer connection string fix — writing to the correct appsettings.*.json fallback — appears across both the v17 and v18 RCs, indicating a shared backport.
What is TinaCMS?
TinaCMS 3.13.0 ships media renaming, image type restrictions, and drops 1.3MB from the admin bundle by lazy-loading Mermaid.
TinaCMS is a Git-backed headless CMS shipping as a monorepo of npm packages. The 3.13.0 release is the substantive one this cycle: media renaming from the Media Manager (with editorial workflow support for protected branches), image field `accept` attribute for restricting file types, semantic `<thead>/<th>` in markdown tables (breaking CSS change), and a significant bundle reduction — the Mermaid library moved to a lazy-loaded chunk, trimming the admin entry from 6.3MB to 5.7MB gzipped.
Umbraco CMS vs TinaCMS: editorial side-by-side
Umbraco CMS
5.0MARKETING
Umbraco runs parallel release candidates across v13, v17, and v18, with both current tracks approaching their next minor GA.
◆ Current state
Umbraco is running a steady cadence of release candidates across three active version tracks: v13 (LTS), v17 (current stable), and v18 (latest). The visible changes are mostly dependency updates and targeted bug fixes. The installer connection string fix — writing to the correct appsettings.*.json fallback — appears across both the v17 and v18 RCs, indicating a shared backport.
◆ Where it's heading
The parallel RC activity across v17 and v18 suggests both tracks are close to minor GA releases. The v18 track removed the @hey-api/openapi-ts dependency from the login module, a sign of ongoing internal housekeeping as the v18 API surface stabilizes. No large feature work is visible in recent entries; this is a stabilization and maintenance phase.
◆ Prediction
v18.2.0 and v17.7.0 will ship to stable shortly after the RC cycle, with v18 continuing to accumulate UX and developer experience improvements while v17 and v13 receive security and compatibility maintenance.
TinaCMS
6.3MARKETING
TinaCMS 3.13.0 ships media renaming, image type restrictions, and drops 1.3MB from the admin bundle by lazy-loading Mermaid.
◆ Current state
TinaCMS is a Git-backed headless CMS shipping as a monorepo of npm packages. The 3.13.0 release is the substantive one this cycle: media renaming from the Media Manager (with editorial workflow support for protected branches), image field `accept` attribute for restricting file types, semantic `<thead>/<th>` in markdown tables (breaking CSS change), and a significant bundle reduction — the Mermaid library moved to a lazy-loaded chunk, trimming the admin entry from 6.3MB to 5.7MB gzipped.
◆ Where it's heading
TinaCMS is building out content management completeness — media lifecycle operations (rename was a notable gap), richer field validation, and better editor fidelity (markdown hard breaks, table semantics). Bundle size attention suggests the product is being tuned for real-world adoption where admin load time matters. Session expiry flow now handles the case cleanly, which matters for TinaCloud commercial accounts.
◆ Prediction
The editorial workflow (branch-based content workflows for protected repos) will likely get further polish as media operations expand. The broken admin bundle size trend suggests performance optimization may become a sustained focus.
Alternatives to Umbraco CMS and TinaCMS
Other Marketing products tracked by Sparkpulse, ranked by recent ship velocity. Each card links to a full editorial trajectory and lets you pivot into a head-to-head comparison with either Umbraco CMS or TinaCMS.
Statusbrew
Statusbrew expands its rules engine with property-based triggers and adds AI-driven image cropping to Compose
Swello
Swello adds team post approval and multi-language AI writing to its social scheduling core.
WP Tasty
WP Tasty closes the Lite-to-paid gap while wiring its plugin suite tighter
Schema & Structured Data for WP
Schema Pro v2.12.0 adds four new schema types — the most coverage expansion this plugin has shipped in a while.
Saleshandy
Saleshandy ships built-in CRM workflow automation and cuts Lead Finder lookup time from 40s to 5s.
See all Umbraco CMS alternatives → · See all TinaCMS alternatives →
Recent activity from Umbraco CMS and TinaCMS
Latest ship moves from both products, interleaved chronologically. ⚡ = editorial spark.
- 9d agoTinaCMStinacms-gitprovider-github@4.1.17 — npm metadata fix
- 9d agoTinaCMStinacms-authjs@24.0.4 — metadata fix, bump to 3.13.0
- 9d agoTinaCMStinacms@3.13.0
- 9d agoTinaCMS@tinacms/webpack-helpers@1.0.6 — npm metadata fix
- 9d agoTinaCMS@tinacms/vercel-previews@0.2.20 — metadata fix, bump to 3.13.0
- 9d agoTinaCMS@tinacms/schema-tools@2.10.0 — image accept, session expired listener API
- 13d agoUmbraco CMSUmbraco 18.2.0 release candidate
- 13d agoUmbraco CMSUmbraco 17.7.0 release candidate
- 1mo agoUmbraco CMSUmbraco 18.1.0 RC2 — migration and auth fixes
- 1mo agoUmbraco CMSUmbraco 17.6.0 RC2 — auth and notification fixes
- 1mo agoUmbraco CMSUmbraco 18.1.0 RC — login module cleanup and UI upgrades
- 1mo agoUmbraco CMSUmbraco 17.6.0 release candidate
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between Umbraco CMS and TinaCMS?
They serve adjacent needs but don't currently overlap on shipped themes. TinaCMS is currently shipping more aggressively (velocity 6.3 vs 5.0), with 0 editorial sparks in the last 30 days against 0. See the at-a-glance table above for a side-by-side breakdown of velocity, recent sparks, and editorial themes.
Is Umbraco CMS better than TinaCMS?
Sparkpulse doesn't pick a winner — we score release velocity, not feature parity. TinaCMS is currently shipping more aggressively (velocity 6.3 vs 5.0), with 0 editorial sparks in the last 30 days against 0. For your specific use case, the alternatives sections above list other Marketing products to evaluate alongside.
What are the best alternatives to Umbraco CMS?
Top Umbraco CMS alternatives in Marketing are ranked by recent ship velocity. Browse the "Umbraco CMS alternatives" section above for the current picks, or visit /alternatives/umbraco for the full list with editorial commentary on each.
What are the best alternatives to TinaCMS?
Top TinaCMS alternatives in Marketing are ranked by recent ship velocity. Browse the "TinaCMS alternatives" section above for the current picks, or visit /alternatives/tinacms for the full list with editorial commentary on each.